70 Halloween Would You Rather Questions

Halloween Would You Rather Questions About Costumes

Tails, capes, cardboard robots and the yearly fight over wearing a coat on top of the costume.

1. Would you rather wear a costume that lights up in the dark or one that makes a sound when you walk?
2. Would you rather dress up as your pet or have your pet dress up as you?
3. Would you rather wear a matching costume with your whole family or pick a costume nobody else has?
4. Would you rather make your costume out of cardboard boxes or wear one straight from the store?
5. Would you rather wear a costume with a giant tail or one with wings that flap?
6. Would you rather wear a costume that is way too hot or one that is a little too itchy?
7. Would you rather dress up as a food or dress up as an animal?
8. Would you rather wear a costume you can't sit down in or one you can barely see out of?
9. Would you rather dress up as a character from your favorite book or the job you want someday?
10. Would you rather go as a giant crayon or go as a walking pumpkin?
11. Would you rather wear a mask that covers your whole face or face paint that takes an hour to put on?
12. Would you rather have a costume with a secret candy pocket or a costume with a built-in flashlight?
13. Would you rather be a robot made of boxes or a knight made of tinfoil?
14. Would you rather win the prize for funniest costume or the prize for most creative costume?
15. Would you rather wear a costume nobody can guess or one everyone guesses right away?
16. Would you rather let your grown-ups pick your costume or pick the costumes your grown-ups wear?
17. Would you rather wear a costume made of balloons or a costume made of paper plates?
18. Would you rather start planning your costume in July or pick it the night before Halloween?
19. Would you rather wear your winter coat over your costume or stay a little chilly so everyone sees it?
20. Would you rather dress as a friendly monster with three eyes or a friendly monster with six arms?

Halloween Would You Rather Questions About Candy

Trading, sorting, the parent candy tax and the house that hands out toothbrushes.

21. Would you rather trade your whole bag for one huge candy bar or keep your mixed bag of little treats?
22. Would you rather eat all your candy on Halloween night or make it last until Thanksgiving?
23. Would you rather sort your candy by color or sort it from favorite to least favorite?
24. Would you rather be the house that gives out full-size candy bars or the house that gives out glow sticks?
25. Would you rather get only chocolate in your bag or get only sour candy?
26. Would you rather find a house that gives two pieces each or a bowl with a "take a handful" sign?
27. Would you rather get raisins in your bag or get a toothbrush in your bag?
28. Would you rather eat a handful of candy corn or a handful of black licorice?
29. Would you rather have a trick-or-treat bucket that never gets heavy or one that never gets full?
30. Would you rather stay home and hand out candy or go trick-or-treating?
31. Would you rather pay your parents a candy tax or hide your bag under the bed?
32. Would you rather find candy that changes flavor as you chew or candy that turns your tongue blue?
33. Would you rather bob for apples or try to eat a donut hanging from a string?
34. Would you rather dump your candy on the floor the minute you get home or wait until morning to look?
35. Would you rather find a candy that tastes like pizza or a candy that tastes like toothpaste?
36. Would you rather eat your favorite candy first or save your favorite for last?
37. Would you rather trick-or-treat for one hour with a giant bag or three hours with a tiny bag?
38. Would you rather walk to fifty houses or ride in a wagon to ten houses?
39. Would you rather eat your candy with your costume gloves still on or with your mask still on?
40. Would you rather get a mystery bag of candy or pick every piece yourself?

Spooky Halloween Would You Rather Questions (Not Scary)

Friendly ghosts, black cats, bats and full moons: spooky enough to feel like Halloween, gentle enough for a 6-year-old at bedtime.

41. Would you rather have a friendly ghost for a roommate or a black cat that talks?
42. Would you rather walk through a haunted house full of silly surprises or a glow-in-the-dark pumpkin patch?
43. Would you rather hear a friendly ghost say "boo" every morning or hear a bat say goodnight every night?
44. Would you rather be a bat for one night or be a black cat for one night?
45. Would you rather carve a happy face into your pumpkin or carve a spooky face?
46. Would you rather have a pet owl that hoots jokes or a pet spider that spins your name in its web?
47. Would you rather see a full moon every night or see a shooting star every night?
48. Would you rather ride a flying broom to school or stir a cauldron that makes any soup you want?
49. Would you rather tell spooky stories with a flashlight or listen to them from inside a sleeping bag?
50. Would you rather have a jack-o'-lantern that talks or a scarecrow that waves at everyone who walks by?
51. Would you rather go to a ghost's birthday party or go to a monster's dance party?
52. Would you rather find a secret door behind a bookshelf or a hidden staircase in the attic?
53. Would you rather cover your house in fake spider webs or line your walkway with glowing jack-o'-lanterns?
54. Would you rather hear creaky stairs every night or hear owls hooting every night?
55. Would you rather live in a castle with a secret tunnel or an old house with a painting that talks?
56. Would you rather be able to walk through walls on Halloween or be able to turn invisible on Halloween?
57. Would you rather have a friendly monster under your bed or a friendly ghost in your closet?
58. Would you rather drink a potion that turns your hair green or one that makes you giggle all night?
59. Would you rather hide a rubber spider in Dad's shoe or find a rubber bat in your cereal box?
60. Would you rather howl at the full moon with your dog or look at it through a telescope?

Halloween Would You Rather Questions for a Road Trip

Ten questions for the drive to the pumpkin patch, the corn maze or your grandparents' street on trick-or-treat night.

61. Would you rather drive to a pumpkin patch close to home or one an hour away with a giant corn maze?
62. Would you rather wear your costume for the whole drive or change into it when you get there?
63. Would you rather get lost in a corn maze for an hour or find your way out in ten minutes?
64. Would you rather trick-or-treat on your own street or drive to your grandparents' neighborhood to trick-or-treat?
65. Would you rather drive slowly past the spookiest decorated houses or walk the neighborhood to see them up close?
66. Would you rather eat candy in the car on the way home or save your bag until you get home?
67. Would you rather have a scarecrow ride in the back seat or a pumpkin buckled into the middle seat?
68. Would you rather hear spooky stories on the drive home or sing silly Halloween songs on the drive home?
69. Would you rather take a bumpy hayride out to the pumpkin field or walk there through the mud?
70. Would you rather count jack-o'-lanterns on porches from the car or count ghost decorations in yards?

Printable Halloween Would You Rather Questions (Free PDF)